- Since January 2024, mobile phones have been banned in Dutch classrooms, except for educational and medical reasons.
- 75% of secondary schools report improved concentration and 59% report a better social climate.
- Academic performance has improved and cyberbullying has decreased, although new challenges have emerged.
- The measure extends to primary school, with a more modest positive impact and flexible policies for special cases.
Dutch education is experiencing times of change following the national ban on mobile phones in classrooms coming into force on January 1, 2024. This measure did not arise from a sudden impulse, but from the consensus between the Ministry of Education, parent associations, teachers, administrators and students, concerned about the negative impact of devices on concentration and social relationships within the school.
After more than a year of implementing the standardThe results are beginning to become evident and have sparked debate beyond the Netherlands' borders. The decision, supported by studies and analyses commissioned by institutions such as the Kohnstamm Institute, is attracting the interest of other European countries closely monitoring the effects of this policy.
Direct results: Concentration and school climate in focus
Since the implementation of the ban, 99% of Dutch schools require students to hand in their cell phones. first thing in the morning or leave it in safes. This regulation only provides for exceptions when the devices are used for educational purposes specific, or in situations of medical need or support for students with special needs.
The first official figures are overwhelming: a 75% of secondary schools recognize improvements in student concentration or with a 59% highlight the reinforcement of a more positive and healthy social climateAlthough academic performance has grown somewhat less (28%), the general perception is positive: Students are more attentive, participate more in class and have resumed the habit of conversation. during breaks.
Furthermore, The report highlights the reduction in cyberbullying and the improvement of interpersonal relationships., something that students themselves have noticed by leaving social media and instant messaging aside during school hours.
Impact and challenges: are they all advantages?
However, the new policy has also brought some unexpected challengesMany teachers report that they now have to devote more time to ensuring compliance with the rule and managing new types of conflicts arising from direct interaction between adolescents. In fact, it has been detected a slight increase in disruptive and aggressive behavior, which forces educational teams to deploy more emotional support strategies.
On the other hand, a sector of the teaching staff and school management, although satisfied, demands adjustments and resources to manage the increased workload associated with device monitoring. The debate remains open about how to address these side effects without sacrificing the primary benefits the measure has brought.
Primary and special education: flexible application
In Dutch primary schools, where mobile phone use was already rare, the ban has had a more moderate but relevant impact. 89% of these schools limit access to mobile phones and require them to be handed in at the beginning of the school day. An improvement in student well-being has been noted. The school environment has also improved significantly, although not so much concentration or performance.
A curious phenomenon is the replacing mobile phones with smart watches, especially in primary school. While these devices are more discreet and difficult to identify, They are not causing any major problems at the moment., although the centers adapt their rules to anticipate future challenges.
In special education, the implementation of the standard incorporates justified exceptions based on medical or pedagogical criteria, allowing controlled access to devices such as connected hearing aids or screen readers, reaffirming an inclusive and personalized commitment.
A model observed in Europe
Dutch politics has awakened the interest of countries such as Spain, the United Kingdom, Norway and Sweden, who are studying the possibility of replicating the model after confirming the positive effects on school coexistence and the mental health of students.
According to UNESCO, The number of countries with restrictive measures on mobile phones in classrooms has grown from 60 to 79 in just two years., confirming the trend toward conscious and regulated digitalization. The Netherlands has opted for a flexible and consensual approach, granting schools a degree of autonomy to implement the measure according to their specific circumstances.
The key to success seems to be in the dialogue between all educational actors and in the desire to adapt technology to the real needs of learning, not the other way around.
Rethinking the role of technology in school
The experience of the Netherlands shows that Banning cell phones in class does not mean demonizing technology.In fact, the goal is to ensure smarter and more beneficial use of digital tools in the classroom. There are exceptions for pedagogical cases specific and for students with medical needs, stressing that the prohibition is neither absolute nor rigid.
The current debate revolves around how to find balance between the benefits provided by digital resources and the need to protect students' concentration, mental health and coexistenceExperts insist that digitalization must serve learning and not negatively impact the school climate.
The commitment to strict but reasonable regulation is marking a turning point in European education. The Dutch experience offers clues as to how other countries can move toward more humane schools and less dependent on hyperconnectivity.
After a year and a half of implementation, Dutch classrooms are recovering spaces for mindfulness and conversation, confirming that setting limits on mobile phone use improves the environment and fosters coexistence. Although not all challenges have disappeared, The general feeling among teachers, families and students is that taking the step has been worth it. and has laid the foundations for a new way of understanding education in digital times.
I am a technology enthusiast who has turned his "geek" interests into a profession. I have spent more than 10 years of my life using cutting-edge technology and tinkering with all kinds of programs out of pure curiosity. Now I have specialized in computer technology and video games. This is because for more than 5 years I have been writing for various websites on technology and video games, creating articles that seek to give you the information you need in a language that is understandable to everyone.
If you have any questions, my knowledge ranges from everything related to the Windows operating system as well as Android for mobile phones. And my commitment is to you, I am always willing to spend a few minutes and help you resolve any questions you may have in this internet world.