Musiyano pakati peantifederalist uye federalist

Chii chinonzi antifederalists?

Vaipikisa hurumende vaiva vaya vaipikisa kusimbiswa kweBumbiro reMitemo reUnited States. United States ya 1787. Vanhu ava vaityira kuumbwa kwehurumende yenyika ine simba, iri pakati nepakati yaigona kutyisidzira kodzero dzehurumende nevagari vemo.

Nharo dzevanopikisa

Antifederalists vakapokana kuti Bumbiro reMitemo rakapa simba rakawandisa kuhurumende yemubatanidzwa nevakuru, vemitemo, uye matavi ematare. Vainetsekawo nokushaikwa kweBhuku Rekodzero muBumbiro reMitemo, iro raidzivirira kodzero dzinokosha dzevagari vemo, dzakadai sorusununguko rwokutaura, rusununguko rwokubudisa nhau, uye rusununguko rwokunamata.

Chii chinonzi federalists?

Vemubatanidzwa ndivo vaitsigira zvakasimba kugadzwa kweBumbiro reMitemo kubva kuUnited States ya1787. Vanhu ava vaidavira kuti hurumende yenyika yakasimba yaidiwa kuchengetedza kodzero nerusununguko rwehurumende uye vagari vemo.

Nharo dzeve federalists

MaFederalist akapokana kuti kusikwa kwehurumende yakasimba, yepakati penyika kwakakosha kudzivirira hudzvinyiriri uye mhirizhonga. Vaidavira kuti gadziriro yehurumende yakanyatsorongeka, yakakamurwa kuva mapazi akaparadzana uye ichishanda necheki uye zviyereso, ndiyo yakanga iri nzira yakanakisisa yokudzivirira kodzero dzevagari vemo mumwe nomumwe uye kusimudzira kugara zvakanaka kwenyika.

Misiyano pakati pevanopikisa uye federalists

Basa rehurumende

• Antifederalists vaitenda kuti hurumende yemubatanidzwa inofanirwa kuve isina kusimba uye isina kukwana, nepo maFederalist aiti hurumende yenyika inofanirwa kuve yakasimba uye pakati.
• MaAntifederalists aipikisa hutungamiri hwakasimba uye dare remubatanidzwa, nepo maFederalist aida hutungamiri hwakasimba uye dare remubatanidzwa.

Kudzivirirwa kwekodzero

• Antifederalists vaidavira kuti Bumbiro reMitemo rakanga risingape dziviriro yakakwana yekodzero dzevanhu uye kuti kusavapo kweBhuku Rekodzero kwaiva kukanganisa kukuru.
• MaFederalist aitenda kuti Bhiri reKodzero rakanga risingaverengeki, sezvo chimiro checheki uye zviyero muBumbiro reMitemo zvaizodzivirira zvakakwana kodzero dzemunhu.

Muchidimbu, maAntifederalists uye maFederalist vaive nemafungiro akasiyana zvakanyanya nezve basa uye chiyero chehurumende yemubatanidzwa uye kudiwa kweBhiri reKodzero muBumbiro reMitemo. VaAntifederalist vaida hurumende isina simba, isina kukwana, asi maFederalist aida hurumende yakasimba, yepakati. Antifederalists vaitenda kuti Bumbiro reMitemo raida Bhiri reKodzero kuchengetedza kodzero dzemunhu, nepo maFederalist aitenda kuti chimiro cheBumbiro reMitemo chaizopa dziviriro yakakwana yekodzero dzemunhu.

Mukupedzisa, mutsauko uripo pakati peAntifederalists neveFederalists wakanangana nehukuru uye chiyero chehurumende yemubatanidzwa uye kudiwa kweBhiri reKodzero muBumbiro reMitemo.